Posts Tagged ‘India’

Glenn Beck needs to get out more

Friday, December 11th, 2009

He shows just how much of a bigoted idiot his is every day.  There’s a lot of stuff in this clip, but I’m just going to focus on the stuff he says about India.  I’ve spent some time there and been to the hospital there (for minor stuff).  Glenn hasn’t been to India and, like always, has no idea what the bloody fuck he is talking about.

First, getting the math right:

The average per capital income of an Indian is not $1,016, it is $749.80.  I got that from the Central Statistical Organisation in India converting their estimates from INR to USD (divide by 50).  That’s across all professions.  The average real disposable personal income per capita in the US (according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis) is about $32,000.  Not the $27,000 Glenn claims it is.

More specifically, he talks about doctors in India having an income of $5,760 and in the US it being $150,000.  There aren’t any official studies or statistics, but a specialist in an expensive city like Bangalore would have an income of around $10,000.  A doctor in the US could be paid between 100 and 800 thousand dollars depending on their specialty and how many years they’ve practiced.

Of course, one of the problems with having doctors get such high salaries is that people who want to make money rather than help patients go for those kinds of jobs.

And “Mumbai clinic at Punjab,” Glenn?  Can we make a law that you have to know at least a certain amount of stuff before being put on a TV news network?  Like Mumbai being a city that’s several hundred miles from Punjab (which is a state)

As an aside, one nice thing about the Mayo clinic is that doctors there are paid on a fixed salary, rather than by how many procedures they do, so the incentive to do more (thus driving up costs for the patient) is not there.  By the way, not everybody can just walk into the Mayo clinic and get treatment, by the way.

Also, Glenn, “Gaja Raja medical school” doesn’t exists and you probably know that.  A real medical school like the All India Institute of Medical Sciences is considered one of the best medical schools in the world.

And do you honestly think that flush toilets don’t exist in India?  What rock do you live under?

Will this change stick?

Sunday, October 25th, 2009

The Indian state of Orissa has changed its name to Odisha as part of the BJP’s long campaign to indianize place names to change names that have colonial implications such as Bombay or Calcutta (now Mumbai and Kolkata).

Most people, including me, have gotten used to Mumbai, or calling Madras “Chennai,”  but almost nobody calls Bangalore “Bengaluru,”  so I don’t know how well “Odisha” will stick.

India’s drought

Saturday, September 5th, 2009

India has a drought.  I knew it because I travelled around the north of the country during the “monsoon season” and was rarely rained on.

Last year, one of Project Censored’s top underreported stories was the mass suicide of farmers and the connection between the mass suicide and the allowance of large US Agriculture corporations to take over farm land and force individual farmers to compete against them.

PM Manmohan Singh was part of the deal.  He and the Congress party promised to help struggling farmers and in the last elections, they won more seats over the BJP, which also promised to help.

Everybody who has written about India’s future in the last few years has noted that there are two India’s: the one that has reaped the benefits of the 1991 economic reforms and the one that has not, and that we should pay attention to the latter while praising the former.  The New York Times has an article this morning about that other India.

In India itself, the big news story has been the in-fighting in the BJP that’s been going on since the election in May, but heated up recently because the former home minister Jaswant Singh wrote a book that praised the father of Pakistan, Mohammed Ali Jinnah and put blame for partition on Jawaharlal Nehru and the Congress party.  He’s since been expelled and has been ratting everyone else out.

That story’s been the only story on Indian news channels (and if not that, swine flu).  The only story about the hardships of starving Indians I saw while I was there was on the BBC.  Underreported indeed.

Hyderabad

Thursday, August 6th, 2009

City of Nizams.  Hyderabad was built in the 1580s to accomidate the growing size of nearby Golconda.  For centuries it was one of the richest cities in India due to the wealth that the Golconda diamond mines, the only known diamond mines in the world until the late 18th century, brought in.  The Hope Diamond was mined there, and its “cursed” history is thought to be because it was stolen from the eye of a statue of Sita (the story was invented in the Victorian era, and not reliable).

In 1591, Muhammed Quli Qutb Shah (above), the Sultan of Golconda built a mosque at the center of the city with four roads heading out in the cardinal directions, supposedly because he wanted to build the city based on the map of heaven provided in the Qu’ran.  The grounds of the Taj Mahal, which was built 50 years after the Charminar, are also based on this map.

The Russian mystic H. P. Blavatsky wrote about the Charminar in her travelogue “From the Caves and Jungles of Hindostan“:

 in the unanimous opinion of travelers and antiquarians, the most interesting building of Hyderabad is Chahar-Minar, a college that was built by Mohamed-Kuli-Khan on the ruins of a still more ancient college. It is built at the crossing of four streets, on four arches, which are so high that loaded camels and elephants with their turrets pass through freely. Over these arches rise the several stories of the college. Each story once was destined for a separate branch of learning. Alas! the times when India studied philosophy and astronomy at the feet of her great sages are gone, and the English have transformed the college itself into a warehouse. The hall, which served for the study of astronomy, and was filled with quaint, medieval apparatus, is now used for a depot of opium; and the hall of philosophy contains huge boxes of liqueurs, rum and champagne, which are prohibited by the Koran, as well as by the Brahmans.

Enchanting, but it’s best to take Blavatsky’s words with a grain of salt.  The Charminar was built as a mosque, which is on the fourth floor of the building (closed to the public).

Hyderabad is a mix of two cultures, Hindu and Muslim.  Hindus speak primarily Telugu, while Muslims primarily speak Urdu.  All signs are in English and one of these languages, while official signs are in all three.

The Taj Mahal was built by Shah Jahan, who started expanding the Mughal Empire into the Deccan during his reign.  His son, Aurangzeb, completed the conquests in 1687 after he conquered and sacked Hyderabad.  He ended the Qutb Shah dynasty.  This was especially pleasing to Aurangzeb, a Sunni Muslim, who defeated the Shi’ite Qutb Shah dynasty, who culturally identified themselves with Safavid Persia, a longtime foe of the Mughals.  One of Shah Jahan’s humiliating defeats was when Kandahar was conquered by the Persians in 1653.

Muhammed Qutb Shah had begun building the Mecca Masjid, just south of the Charminar, in 1617.  It was finally completed in 1694 when Aurangzeb ruled the city.

After Aurangzeb’s death in 1707, Hyderabad State declared itself independent in 1724, and by that time, the next dynasty of rulers, the Nizams (named after the first, Nizam Ali Khan) came to power.  The French had a resident in Hyderabad by 1756, but withdrew after the Seven Years War.

One of the places I didn’t get to was the British Residency, built by James Kirkpatrick, the British Resident at Hyderabad at the turn of the 19th century.  He’s also the subject of William Dalrymple’s book “White Mughals” which I’m reading now.  Kirkpatrick essentially “went native” at a time when such a thing was strongly discouraged by the British East India Company and the Governor-General Lord Wellesly (and his predecessor, Lord Cornwallis.  THAT Lord Cornwallis)

Kirkpatrick married Khair-un-Nissa, a Hyderabadi noblewoman (above).  Another Englishman who did this was William Palmer, who was the British Resident at Pune until 1800 when he was removed by Lord Wellesly.  He left soon afterwards and stayed in Hyderabad, where he became good friends with Kirkpatrick while his wife, Fyze, became good friends with Kahir. 

Palmer’s granddaughter, Mary, married the novelist Phillip Meadows Taylor, who was a clerk for the Nizam.  Taylor’s novel “Confessions of a Thug” introduced the world to the mysterious Thuggee Cult and introduced the word “thug” into the English language.

Taylor would later write “Seeta” which sympathetically portrayed a marriage between a British civil servant and a Hindu widow.

In 1857, Hyderabad State became a Princely State in British India.  The Nizam continued to rule, but the British resident made sure he stayed in line.

During this time, among the many architectural wonders constricuted by the Nizam were Osmania Hospital (above) and the Andhra Pradesh High Court (below and close detail further below)

In 1947, India became an independent nation, and Hyderabad State was given the option to join India, Pakistan or become independent.  The Nizam wanted to remain independent, an action that was supported by Pakistan.  India launched Operation Polo and removed the Nizam government on September 17, 1948. 

In 1956, Hyderabad State was renamed Andhra Pradesh and its borders redrawn after many other states were similarly redrawn along linguistic boundaries (Mysore State became Karnataka, Travancore Cochin state became Kerala and so on)

The Nizam left the throne in 1956 and retired in Australia.  He died in 1967.  Hyderabad is now a major IT hub, but I couldn’t see much of the IT cities from where I was.  The old city still looks old.

Don’t be afraid. Don’t be very afraid, Senator

Saturday, July 25th, 2009

Shh.  It’s okay, they’re not out to get you.  India’s not a threat to the U. S., Senator.  I know you want those fighter jets to be built, but citing made up enemies doesn’t help you.

Sec. Clinton in India and Glenn Beck

Wednesday, July 22nd, 2009

So I don’t get Fox News here in India (thank goodness!) but I’ve heard that Glenn Beck went nuts there a few days ago, even more than usual.  In the course of it he called Sec. Hillary Clinton’s trip to India an “apology tour” where he believes Clinton is going around apologizing for all the bad things America’s done.

The trip has been all over the Indian media and I can tell you it’s not an apology tour.  And besides,whatever the US has did bad to India happened decades ago (Nixon and Indira Gandhi didn’t speak to each other).

Clinton has left India by now, but what she did accomplish was an agreement that the US would inspect nuclear sites and equipment being used for nuclear technology in India.  The opposition is furious, calling it a breach of national sovereignty.

Clinton pushed for India to accept a greenhouse emission cap and to sign nuclear weapon treaties, but India rejected both.

No apologies on behalf of America.  Where did you pull that out of, Glenn?

Mamallapuram

Thursday, July 16th, 2009

Clea and Rob have joined Nick and me at the paper, so Krish decided to send us all on a day trip to Mamallapuram, which I had been planning to go to on a weekend.  On the way there, we drove through the fish market, which is something I plan to take a closer look at later.

Mamallapuram is thought to be named after Mammala, a Pallava King in the 7th century also known as Narasimhavarman I.  The Pallavas built many of their structures out of rock.  Some of them, like the one below, were left incomplete after the Pallava’s were conquered by their longtime enemy, the Chola empire.

Many of the places at Mamallapuram, which served as a port city to the Pallava kingdom, are UNESCO World Heritage sites.  One of them is the Pancharathas, meaning Five Chariots.  They are monolithic structures, meaning that they are carved out of a single rock.  Supposedly they are named after the Pandavas of the Mahabharata (sons of Pandu), but the plaque at the site says they’re not.

(That elephant in the last shot is life size)

There’s a lighthouse by the coast which has a small temple underneath which has a relief showing Parvathi (Shiva’s consort) slaying a demon

Opposite to that is a depiction of Vishnu in a deep sleep, dreaming the universe.

In the center is a relief of Shiva and Parvathi with their infant son Ganesha (you can tell by the snake, which is prominent in Ganesh iconography)

The old light house has some Pallava carvings on it, and it has a spectacular view of the coast, and the new light house

More views from the light house (toward the coast and inland)

Entrance to the shore temple

There was also this great anti-littering sign

There is another relief nearby showing Indra holding up the sky

And lions

In the 14th century, the descendants of the Pallava’s, the Kadava’s, added a roof to this temple.

A 14th century optical illusion.  Is it a cow or an elephant?

The highlight of the trip was “Arjuna’s Penance”, a large relief that shows Arjuna (or possibly Bhagiratha) praying for rain and Shiva unleashing the Ganges towards Earth (with a Vishnu temple).  Those elephants are life size.

That’s the Vishnu temple above.

Shiva answering Arjuna’s (or Bhagiratha’s) penance – he’s the skinny one on the right performing the penance.

We capped off the day with a visit to a place that had constructed traditional south Indian homes and all of us put henna on our hands.  Even the boys, even though its usually done to girls.  It’ll be on my hand for a week, so I’ll have plenty of people coming up to me and asking why on Earth I’ve got it on my hand, but whatever.

It’s painted on your hand and you have to wait for an hour before scratching it off to reveal the decoration.  Here’s mine before and after.

Uygher Riots and India in America

Wednesday, July 8th, 2009

I’ll deal with two topics in one post this time.  Just because.

First, Kamla Bhatt talked a few days ago about how India is connected to the US in two little-known ways.  First, Francis Scott Key wrote the national anthem on the HMS Minden, which was built by a British ship-making company in India.  It’s supposedly the first Indian built ship commissioned by the British.  Second, Yale University is named after its first benefactor, Elihu Yale, who served as the British Governor of Madras twice in the late 1600′s.

Secondly, not as well covered as the Michael Jackson funeral are the riots in Xinjiang, China between Han Chinese and native Uyghers.  Radio Free Asia has the latest news, as does the blog EastSouthWestNorth  Official Chinese media have given one story, while independent agencies have given different ones, which Imagethief looks at.  The Government’s also banned Twitter and Facebook in order to stop people from organizing.  Taiwan remains silent on the riots, which The Far-Eastern Sweet Potato doesn’t like.

Just days before the riots started, Juliana Rincon Para at Global Voices took a look at Uyghers and their persecution by the government.

BREAKING: 377 repealed

Thursday, July 2nd, 2009

The Delhi High Court just repealed article 377 of the Indian Penal Code which criminalized homosexuality.  Today’s a good day.

Chennai Gay pride march more stuff

Monday, June 29th, 2009

The event was well covered by journalists.  The Hindu, Deccan Chronicle and the Times all had stories on it.  Anand Grafti has pictures in his photostream.  The DC also had a counterpoint article written by a correspondent (Indian newspapers have this annoying habit of printing articles with no author).

Chennai Daily Photo has more.